Hiring an Editor: Who, When, Why, and How to Avoid Scams – by Anne R. Allen…

Learning to write books is hard. Earning money from books is even harder. So some writers figure they’ll bypass the expensive stuff like hiring an editor.

This is not a good idea if you’re planning to self-publish. We are all blind to our own mistakes. And newbies especially need help in shaping and polishing a book.

But what if you’re going the query route? Do you need to hire an editor before you start sending out a book to agents and small presses?

What an Editor Can (and Can’t) Do

Newbies often aren’t clear about what editors do. When I worked as a freelance editor, I was amazed by the number of people who came to me with over-inflated ideas of what I could do for them.

They’d arrive with collections of transcriptions of court proceedings, notebooks full of verses and random jottings, or stacks of old letters they wanted me to make into a commercially viable memoir or novel.

One potential client actually brought a pillowcase full of ancient cassette tapes and dumped them on my dining table and asked me to “edit” them into a book.

I had to tell these people I couldn’t help. Editors polish a manuscript. They don’t create it.

There are people who spin raw verbal straw into book gold. They’re called ghostwriters. If you have a story to tell and don’t feel you can do it yourself, a good ghostwriter can do it for you. I can recommend an excellent ghostwriting service–Your Memoir–where M. Summerfield Smith works with many clients (some high profile) to turn their memories into books. 

But a ghostwriter does more (and costs more) than an editor.

Unless you have deep pockets, if you want to write a book, it’s best to take writing courses, go to conferences, join a critique group and write it yourself. (For memoirists, read my post on writing memoir.) Then hire an editor.

Hiring an Editor


20 thoughts on “Hiring an Editor: Who, When, Why, and How to Avoid Scams – by Anne R. Allen…

  1. Great post, Chris. Two thoughts. First, I can’t believe anyone who publishes a novel or short story without a second set of eyes is serious about a career as a writer. That’s as bad as the person in the quote, “He who represents himself has a fool for a client.” Second, don’t just take someone’s word that they’re a great editor. If you can’t get a reference from another author, go on Amazon and read the reviews of books they’ve edited. You’ll know they’re quality editors if the books received four stars and there were no mentions of spelling, grammar, and usage errors.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. A very good post, Chris. I employed an editor for Silly Willy Goes to Cape Town after I picked up an error in one of my Sir Choc books. We don’t see our own mistakes and friends don’t read with an eye for detail in the same way as an editor does.

    Liked by 1 person


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s