Aliens and guillotines- 6 reasons to break the editing rules.

Sue Vincent's avatarSue Vincent's Daily Echo

sheffield book weekend 468

I was curious. Being a writer, I keep seeing articles about the editing software available online to help writers and, over coffee, I thought I would have a quick look. I browsed a number of them, duly pasting a chunk of text into their little blank boxes to see what they had to offer.

After five minutes, my blood was boiling.

Writers, it seems, are being encouraged to use these programmes. Not, as I mistakenly supposed, in order to check their grammar, spelling and punctuation… say, as an extension to spellcheck or as a different perspective on work we are too fond of, and too involved with, to see clearly. No. We are being encouraged to use them in order to erase our personal voice.

Okay, I know… that probably isn’t entirely fair.

There are those who swear by their usefulness, though these, I suspect, are writers who use such…

View original post 1,431 more words

14 thoughts on “Aliens and guillotines- 6 reasons to break the editing rules.

  1. Great post. Agree with a lot said! I recently discovered the App being referred to- and I have to admit- I do like it. It don’t let it change my voice as a writer though- just makes me think a little more about my text (with regards to adverbs and passive voice). I analyze the actual need of certain words & decide: Is there a better way I can say this? If the answer is yes- I make changes. But this isn’t replacing my editor who is also working with me on my writing. Idk- sometimes I just really like the adverb 🙂

    Liked by 3 people

  2. I agree. I’ve also heard writers complain that their “editor” (a real person, not software) uses things like counting the number of times the word “and” is used, or other global rules. Having been a technical editor for more years than i care to mention, i have to think that kind of “formula editing” takes the place of actual skill. In my humble opinion… 😉

    Liked by 1 person

DON'T BE SHY - LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.